经肾上盏径路和经肾中下盏径路行经皮肾镜取石术的疗效比较
The efficacy comparison of the upper,middle and lower kidney calyx route in percutaneous nephrolithotomy
-
摘要: 目的:比较经肾上盏径路和经肾中下盏径路行经皮肾镜取石术(PCNL)治疗肾结石及输尿管上段结石的疗效。方法:对392例肾结石以及输尿管上段结石患者行PCNL术,分成肾上盏结石或肾盂结石组、肾下盏结石组、鹿角形结石组和输尿管上段结石(合并或不合并肾结石)组。并从一期结石完全清除率、手术时间、穿刺成功率评估经肾上盏径路和经肾中下盏径路的疗效差异。结果:肾上盏结石或肾盂结石组:2种径路手术的一期结石完全清除率分别为89.4%和95.1%,差异无统计学意义(P0.05),手术时间分别为(77.765.04)min和(81.094.14)min,差异有统计学意义(P0.01);肾下盏结石组:2种径路手术的一期结石完全清除率分别为90.9%和80.0%,差异无统计学意义(P=0.572),手术时间分别为(75.329.23)min和(84.515.27)min,差异有统计学意义(P0.05);鹿角形结石组:2种径路手术的一期结石完全清除率分别为88.2%和72.3%,手术时间分别为(118.693.28)min和(141.084.78)min,差异均有统计学意义(P0.05和P0.01);输尿管上段结石组:2种径路手术的一期结石完全清除率分别为89.7%和64.0%,手术时间分别为(98.986.12)min和(115.566.98)min,差异均有统计学意义(P0.05和P0.01)。穿刺成功率均为100%。结论:对于鹿角形结石组和输尿管上段结石,经肾上盏径路的手术结石清除率更高,手术时间更短。Abstract: ObjectiveTo compare the effects of the upper,middle and lower kidney calyx route in the treatment of kidney and upper ureteral calculi through percutaneous nephrolithotomy( PCNL) . Methods: Three hundred and ninty-two cases with kidney and upper ureteral calculi were treated with PCNL, and divided into the upper renal calyx calculi or pelvic stones, lower renal calyx calculi, antler shape stone and upper ureteral calculi( complicating with or without kidney stone) group.The first period calculi completely clearance and puncture success rate,and operation time of the upper,middle and lower kidney calyx route were compared.Results: The first period calculi completely clearance rate and operation time of the upper renal calyx calculi or pelvic stones group through the upper and middle and lower kidney calyx route were 89.4% & 95.1% and( 77.76 5.04) &( 81.09 4.14) minutes, respectively.Their differences had statistical or no statistical significance( P 0.05 and P 0.01) .The first period calculi completely clearance rate of the lower renal calyx calculi group through the upper and middle and lower kidney calyx route were 90.9% and 80.0%, respectively,which had no statistical significance( P = 0.572) , the operation time were( 75.32 9.23) and( 84.5 15.27) minutes, respectively,which had statistical significance( P 0.05) .The first period calculi completely clearance rate and operation time of the antler shape stone group through the upper and middle and lower kidney calyx route were 88.2% & 72.3% and( 118.69 3.28) &( 141.08 4.78)minutes, respectively.Their differences had statistical significance ( P 0.05 and P 0.01 ) .The first period calculi completely clearance rate and operation time of the upper ureteral calculi group through the upper and middle and lower kidney calyx route were89.7% & 64.0% and( 98.98 6.12) &( 115.56 6.98) minutes, respectively.Their differences had statistical significance( P 0.05 and P 0.01) .The puncture success rates of all cases are 100%. Conclusions: The calculi clearance rates of the antler shape stone and upper ureteral calculi through the upper kidney calyx route is higher, and its operation time is shorter.